So I'm all in for the re-writing series for her classics (and other classic novels). And I love Alexander McCall Smith. Put the two together? Good clean fun.
The plot mostly follows Ms. Austen's original with a few minor changes and lots of modern additions (gym membership, university attendance, fancy cars, and climate change). I loved the quaint, plucky language Mr. Smith uses to give the formality of the classic Austen era - the writing was delightful.
my source: looking for another book at Reader's World in hometown Holland
my verdict: as far as a Jane re-writing - this is a good (not great) one ... better, I thought, than Sense and Sensibility
If you haven't read Alexander McCall Smith's The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency go do that.